Vol. 11, Issue 4 (2025)

A prospective and retrospective study to evaluate the functional outcome of single hamstring tendon ACL reconstruction with internal bracing versus double hamstring tendon ACL reconstruction without internal bracing

Author(s):

R Shree Shanmuga, Lokesh A Veerappa and Sudarsana Gopalan N

Abstract:

Background: Anterior cruciate ligament tears range from 0.24 to 0.34 injuries per 1000 people. Internal brace is a high-strength suture tape which act as a "safety belt," and secondary stabilizer sharing the load of the graft and helps to reduce the re-tear rate, improve graft integrity and enhance knee function potentially improving overall surgical outcomes. Considering the advantage of using internal brace, this study was taken up.

Methods: 60 patients who underwent surgery at Manipal hospital, Bangalore from November 2022-November 2024 were considered for the study. Patients were divided into 2 groups,30 in internal bracing with single hamstring tendon reconstruction group and remaining 30 in without internal bracing with double hamstring tendon reconstruction group. Both groups were assessed with Lysholm knee score and IKDC score pre-operatively and post-operatively at regular intervals.

Results: Both scores showed statistically significant improvement (P<0.001) during the post-operative period in internal bracing group. In internal bracing group, Lysholm score at 3rd month was 83.4,6th month was 90.4 and 12th month was 95.9 while in without internal bracing group at 3rd month was 80.3,6th month was 86.8 and 12th month was 92.7. In internal bracing group 56.67% scored IKDC grade B at 3rd month, 6th month 70% scored grade A and 12th month 100% scored grade A. In without internal bracing group 50% scored grade B at 3rd month, 6th month 66.67% scored grade A and 12th month 93.33% scored grade A. There was no co-relation between the functional outcome scores with respect to age, gender and side of the knee being operated in both groups.

Conclusion: Single hamstring tendon with internal bracing group showed better functional outcome scores than the other group and also returned to pre-injury status as early as 6th month post-operatively. No re-tear of grafts was noted in either of the groups.

Pages: 123-131  |  159 Views  78 Downloads

How to cite this article:
R Shree Shanmuga, Lokesh A Veerappa and Sudarsana Gopalan N. A prospective and retrospective study to evaluate the functional outcome of single hamstring tendon ACL reconstruction with internal bracing versus double hamstring tendon ACL reconstruction without internal bracing. Int. J. Orthop. Sci. 2025;11(4):123-131. DOI: 10.22271/ortho.2025.v11.i4b.3839